Digital Access

Digital Access
Access saukvalley.com from all your digital devices and receive breaking news and updates from around the area.

Home Delivery

Home Delivery
Local news, prep sports, Chicago sports, local and regional entertainment, business, home and lifestyle, food, classified and more! News you use every day! Daily, Daily including the e-Edition or e-Edition only.

Text Alerts

Text Alerts
Choose your news! Select the text alerts you want to receive: breaking news, prep sports scores, school closings, weather, and more. Text alerts are a free service from SaukValley.com, but text rates may apply.

Email Newsletters

Email Newsletters
We'll deliver news & updates to your inbox. Sign up for free e-newsletters today.
Professional

Coin toss a dumb tiebreaker

Shani Davis will not be the U.S. flag bearer for the Opening Ceremonies after the two-time gold medalist lost a coin-toss tiebreaker with Erin Hamlin. (Soeren Stache/DPA/Abaca Press/TNS)
Shani Davis will not be the U.S. flag bearer for the Opening Ceremonies after the two-time gold medalist lost a coin-toss tiebreaker with Erin Hamlin. (Soeren Stache/DPA/Abaca Press/TNS)

GANGNEUNG, South Korea – Shani Davis would’ve been a fitting choice to carry the American flag into the Olympic opening ceremony, a superb athlete who helped break racial barriers at the Winter Games.

Someone sure dropped the coin on this one.

The U.S. Olympic Committee, an organization that never passes up a chance to shoot itself in the foot, came up with a voting process that could quite plausibly end in a tie.

It did, of course.

And how was the deadlock broken?

With the flip of a coin.

Whether it was heads or tails, we may never know. But the call went in favor of Erin Hamlin, so the luger will have the honor of carrying the Stars and Stripes into the stadium tonight.

“Maybe the process is a tad flawed,” said Joey Mantia, one of Davis’ teammates on the U.S. speedskating team.

No doubt.

While Hamlin is certainly deserving – she’ll be competing in her fourth and final Olympics at Pyeongchang – her résumé pales in comparison. Her only Olympic medal is a bronze. The 35-year-old Davis has two golds and a pair of silvers, not to mention a bunch of world championships and the second-most World Cup titles for any male skater in the history of the sport.

Beyond the stellar results, Davis has been a trailblazer.

An African-American in a mostly white sport, he became the first black athlete to win an individual gold medal at the Winter Games with his 1,000-meter triumph in 2006. Four years later, he became the first skater – of any color – to defend his title in that event.

“I don’t think there’s been an African-American flag bearer, ever, for the Winter Games,” Mantia pointed out, correctly. “That would’ve been really cool.”

Davis took offense at how it all went down or, at the very least, expressed his frustrations through whoever was running his verified Twitter account on Thursday.

He implied that race played a factor in the decision.

“I am an American and when I won the 1000m in 2010 I became the first American to 2-peat in that event,” the tweet said. “@TeamUSA dishonorably tossed a coin to decide its 2018 flag bearer. No problem. I can wait until 2022. #BlackHistoryMonth2018.”

Trouble is, Davis isn’t likely to get another chance at carrying the flag. He would have to keep skating until he’s 39 to make it to Beijing. These Olympics – his fifth – are largely viewed as the farewell to a brilliant career, even by his teammates.

“It’s sad that Shani wanted it and didn’t get it, and this is probably his last Olympics,” Mantia said, shrugging off Davis’ reference to 2022. “I think he’s just saying that in jest.”

The flag bearer is selected by a panel of athletes representing each of the eight Winter Olympic federations. After several rounds of balloting, the final round of voting came down to Davis and Hamlin. The USOC, clearly aware a tie was possible, let it be known before the games that a coin flip would be used to decide the winner if that happened.

Such a lazy edict.

Perhaps even more puzzling is why Davis wasn’t the overwhelming choice among his fellow U.S. athletes.

“On paper, it doesn’t make sense for anybody else to do it,” Mantia said. “Nobody is more deserving, in my opinion.”

Even Hamlin laughed off the possibility of carrying the flag when it was suggested to her a couple of months ago.

“That always seems to be a really big-name person,” she said.

But let’s remember: The choice of flag bearer goes beyond mere athletic accomplishment. It’s also a popularity contest, and the perception of Davis – framed by a prickly relationship with the U.S. media, his longstanding decision to train separately from the national team, and a much-publicized feud with fellow American Chad Hedrick during the 2006 Games – might have persuaded some voters to go with Hamlin.

That, too, would be a shame.

But the USOC can come up with a better process for picking the flag bearer.

This should be a feel-good moment. It shouldn’t come down to the flip of a coin.

While Davis has surely rubbed a few people the wrong way, the vast majority of his fellow skaters talk glowingly about his impact on U.S. speedskating, and a willingness to share his wealth of knowledge with the next generation.

“He looks after the younger people like me and gives great advice,” said 21-year-old Emery Lehman, who will be competing in his second Olympics at Pyeongchang. “He’s not selfish at all.”

Let’s hope race didn’t play a factor, but it’s impossible to deny that an outspoken black athlete faces a much greater chance of backlash from a largely white fan base, the mostly white media and, yes, even some fellow athletes who are white.

Those issues, a long time in the making, won’t be settled anytime soon.

Loading more