Poor finish leaves Sox with decisions to make

"One of the biggest questions moving into this offseason will be how many left-handers can you have in your rotation," Williams responded Wednesday night before seldom-used Dan Johnson hit three home runs to pace a five-homer attack in a 9-0 victory over the Indians. "It's a pretty good problem to have."

Gavin Floyd, who could become a free agent if the Sox don't pick up his $9.5 million option for 2013, pitched seven innings of three-hit ball that concluded the Sox's 85-77 season.

"I've been here in Chicago a while and it would be nice to stay here," Floyd said. "It's really up to them."

What seems less certain is the return of third baseman Kevin Youkilis, who cited family reasons as his main criteria for dictating where he would play.

"My family is always going to come first from here on out," said Youkilis, who married earlier this year and became a father for the first time last month. "Now that I have a family, whatever the best fit for them is. You have to attend to your family first and foremost, and baseball is second. Every decision I make from here on out is through my family."

The Sox are expected to decline the $9 million option on Youkilis, a Cincinnati native who resides in Los Gatos, Calif. The Sox have earmarked about $65 million to seven players for 2013 – not including the options on Peavy ($22 million), Floyd and Youkilis.

Peavy is expected to attract interest from several teams, including the Dodgers. Youkilis has been scouted by the Phillies, and the Rockies and Padres have followed the Sox closely in September.

The Sox were not helped by declining attendance that didn't increase revenue. Youkilis cited the economy as one reason for the lack of large crowds.

"It's very surprising to see with us winning that we were still second fiddle to the Cubs," said Youkilis, who played in front of passionate, sellout crowds in Boston for 8 1/2 seasons. "I thought we had a lot of fun and brought a lot of enjoyment to the fans. There was a great fan base that was there. It seemed like the same people who showed up every night to cheer us on, the die-hards."