AG: Derailment led to massive fish kill

State wants rail company to pay

ROCKFORD – The state is officially linking a fish kill from Grand Detour to Prophetstown in 2009 to a train derailment near Rockford.

This week, Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan filed an amended legal complaint against Canadian National, whose train derailed in east Rockford on July 19, 2009.

Click here to view the document

The incident sparked a daylong fire, killing a woman and injuring nine people. About 700 people were evacuated.

Tens of thousands of gallons of ethanol from the train emptied into a nearby creek, flowed to the Kishwaukee River and ended up in the Rock River, the complaint states.

According to the state, an estimated 72,000 fish died as a result. The state says Canadian National is liable for the value of aquatic life lost, but the attorney general didn’t say what that value was.

Shortly after the derailment, a state conservation police officer investigating the fish kill “smelled a strong, sweet odor” that he recognized as ethanol, the complaint states. He detected the smell at the Oppold Marina in Sterling and at the Arduini Boat Ramp in Rock Falls.

He knew this odor because of experience with an ethanol tanker truck spill on Interstate 88.

The officer saw dead fish along the Rock River from north of Grand Detour, nearly 50 miles downstream from the derailment site, to Prophetstown.

The affected stretch of river is 54 miles. It took that distance to have an effect because of the “time of travel,” said Dan Sallee of the state Department of Natural Resources.

“It’s a biological process of bacteria consuming alcohol [ethanol] compounds and then dying. As they die, they rot, decompose and take the oxygen out of the water,” Sallee said.

With the oxygen levels down, fish become stressed and potentially suffocate, according to the state complaint.

At 9 p.m. July 19, 2009, 19 train cars derailed. Each car contained 30,000 gallons of ethanol, according to the complaint. Thirteen of them caught on fire.

Two cars that didn’t catch on fire spilled their ethanol contents into the surrounding area, flowing into the creek.

According to the complaint, the ethanol reduced food supplies in the Rock River, lowered water quality, left the remaining population less able to respond to adverse conditions and reduced the breeding population.

The attorney general wants Canadian National to reimburse the state Department of Natural Resources for restocking and restoring the river.

Scott Mulford, an attorney general’s spokesman, said the costs are “undetermined at this point.”

The state filed the original complaint in Winnebago County court in 2009, claiming environmental damage from the spill.

“We’re still negotiating a settlement,” Mulford said. “If we can reach a settlement that’s equitable to all parties, that’s certainly advantageous.”

Canadian National spokesman Patrick Waldron said his company continues to work with the attorney general’s office seeking a resolution.

“We disagree with the assertion that the spill caused the fish kill,” he said. “With the pending litigation, we don’t have any further comment.”
 

Story Archived

Only the most recent 7 days of articles are available for free. For articles older than 7 days there is a small fee for retrieval from our archive. If you are a registered member of the site, the content is free just by signing in below.

Please sign in with your Comment Member ID and password.

Did you purchase access?

Member ID:
Password:
Forgot Your Password?
Register to comment.

Purchase Access
To allow for flexibility, we offer a variety of options for purchasing articles:
Purchase options


Having trouble?

If you have any technical difficulties, either with your username and password or with the payment options, please contact us by e-mail at archivedesk@shawmedia.com

Blogs

» Out Here
Out Here

Good or bad? Depends on who you ask

Sometimes readers ask for more good news in the paper. They say we in the media only cover the bad. But one person's positive is another's negative.
» Extra! Extra! - A blog by Chris Heimerman
Extra! Extra! - A blog by Chris Heimerman

My kind of game

I would have gladly paid to take in the game I covered Saturday morning in Morrison.

Reader Poll

Memorial Day weekend heralds the arrival of summer vacation season. How much time do you plan to spend on vacation?

1 week
2 weeks
3 or more weeks
No vacation this year